Perhaps the most
frustrating aspect commonly spotted in most works where a woman is the ‘heroine’,
is the habit of writers/production staff to point out that the character’s
feminine qualities are her downfall. When examining the nearly polar character
descriptions of Katniss and Bella, she deduces that femininity is often seen as
a boundary preventing female protagonists from reaching the same potential as
their male counterparts. Heroines that embody ‘girly’ characteristics are often
portrayed as weak, defenseless and purely driven by the desire of a man.
However, when these feminine attributes are far removed from the character and
she embodies a more ‘masculine’ persona, she is more independent and motivated
by personal goals rather than the goals of a romantic interest. For example, in
Disney’s Sleeping Beauty, the
beautiful princess Aurora is the perfect manifestation of a feminine character.
From her flawless singing voice to her long golden hair, her daintiness is not
easily surpassed. However, the cursed princess speaks sparingly for most of the
film and spends the rest of the hour and a half being rescued by her betrothed
Prince Phillip or the three resourceful fairies that raise her in the forest.
Conversely, Disney’s Mulan breaks the
general gender rules set by the film company’s previous works. Not only does
she openly defy her father in one of the most strictly male-subjugated societies
in Asia but she manages to out-perform the entire Chinese army in defeat an
army of barbaric ruffians, enlisting only the help of a shrimp-sized dragon and
a hapless cricket. The writers of this film make it clear to the audience that
Mulan has abandoned the common conventions of femininity before she goes off to
war, therefore making a distinction between the strength associated with
masculinity and the same associated with femininity. Films often prove to be
inept in terms of pairing femininity with any form of mental and physical
strength. Whether this is a bias or a benign oversight, the film industry has
chosen to portray femininity as a liability rather than an advantage.
Furthermore, Ross claims that young girls are taught to think that imagination
and fantasizing about personal aspirations are punishable offenses. Films like Alice in Wonderland reduce young girls
imaginations to realizations that their worth in society will be predetermined
by more superficial indicators. Since the late 1990s,, the film industry has
been drowned in romantic comedies where women are merely objects of the male
character’s desire and are deprived of the opportunity to aspire to anything
better.
Growing Up Strong
ReplyDeleteAfter reading the article “’Twilight’ vs. ‘Hunger Games’: Why Do So Many Grown-Ups Hate Bella?” by Noah Berlatsky, it made me think about the two leading female male characters. In the Twilight series Bella comes off as a helpless teenager who is always being saved by her male counter parts. I have never been a fan of the twilight series and I now believer this is why. Furthermore, I can relate to why parents don’t like Bella as a role model for their children, especially for young girls. Bella portrays a girl that always needs to be saved and that can’t do anything by herself without completely falling apart. Then you have a Character like Katniss, who play the ultimate badass. Someone who doesn’t need to depend on a man and who can take care of herself with whatever life throws at her. Of course parents look at Katniss as someone their child should want to be; brave, outgoing, strong, and independent.
When you look at Disney movies over the past 60 years, the dynamic of the female roles have seriously changed. In the older movies, you have female princess that have to be saved by their shinning knight in armor; like Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty, and many more. However, I feel that the female characters in children movies have become more powerful, strong and independent. This is apparent in movies like Mulan, Brave, and Lilo and Stitch. I believe that this is great for child it shows them from an early age that you need all these quality to help you in life to be a strong women.
I agree with Noah about how the hunger games and twilight are two very different novels but with two very good messages in both of them. One includes a very strong independent women and one includes a women that knows what she wants out of life and isn’t afraid to go for it. I do not like that most critics go for Katniss over Bella just because Katniss is strong and a fighter, Bella is suppose to be a portrayal of a ordinary girl and she is more like you and me then Katniss will ever be. That is what the author of Twilight was trying to do she was not trying to make this amazing heroine hero that swoops in and saves the day she made a girl that was understandable believable at being just like most every single teenage girl in the world. Though she may have had a few traits that parents did not find desirable in their kids they are honest traits that despite what parents may think most girls feel. Noah Did not touch on that part of the comparison of Bella and Katniss but I find she would agree. As for the Disney movies they are not about a women just finding the perfect man and marrying him they are about a girl finding something that makes her happy and going after it, wanting it and seeking it out. These Disney princess’s are just the same as Bella they are confused on who they want to be and what they want but they still strive for it and even though they may not be a strong and independent as Katniss they are following there dreams which speaks for more. Disney movies are changing from what they used to be with a lot of the characters being strong and independent and not needing or wanting of a man as shown I there latest movies “princess and the frog”, “Brave”, and “frozen” these women in these movies don’t need a man to be happy. But in the end they all need love and that is what Disney movies are about, not stereotypes of women or demeaning feminist, just love.
ReplyDeleteLynson,
ReplyDeleteAfter having read your blog I noticed that you and I share a lot of similar beliefs; with the irritation and irrationality of femininity in female animated cartoon or novel characters. Authors and directors portray these young, beautiful, feminine characters as weak, powerless objects that can only be saved by the strength of a man. When reading Deborah Ross’s, Escape from Wonderland: Disney and the Female Imagination I couldn’t help but disagree. Immediately, Mulan popped into my head! Supporting my opinion that femininity should not be portrayed with girly-ness and complete helplessness if a man was not in the picture. Mulan is a feminine girl who only wishes to honor her family by pleasing the matchmaker and marrying. She is forced to act as a soldier in China’s army for the sake of her father’s health and life. Mulan struggles with her strength and her ability to portray herself as “manly” but overcomes these obstacles with time. Later her secret is revealed and she is forced to leave back home with a dishonorable name but she refuses to quit fighting for her country. In the end Mulan along with a small group of men she befriended in army save all of China by defeating the Huns and she marries a man in whose life she saved. This Disney movie is a great portrait for the young girls of today. It shows that you do not have to be a tough “tom-boy” to be independent or able to fight for your own. It shows that even the girly-est have strength within them and it is possible to have the best of both worlds.
In “Katnis vs. Bella”, I feel as though Noah Berlatsky hits the nail on the head. He takes both overly popular movies and accurately describes what the readers get from reading the novel (or watching the movie in some cases). I completely agree with him when he says that both main characters are perfect depictions of the two types of girls in today’s society; Bella the overly dramatic girly girl and Katnis the independent feminist. I agree with Lynson when he says that feminine qualities should not be seen as a down fall and are often desirable traits when trying to find a lover. I feel as though women have the choice to be a perfect blend of the two if they choose to be however, women want the love and affection which Bella receives causing them to be the girly girl who needs a man in order to survive. This is quickly changing along with the rest of the things in the world. Gay is no longer something that is strictly forbidden, tattoos and piercings are allowed in most work places, and women seem to be taking a stand to these “gender norm’s” as well. As for Deborah Ross, I disagree with her when she says that Disney’s main purpose is to influence and brain wash the young ladies who are watching their movies. I honestly believe that they are in it to make a buck here and there. They target young children because that’s where these stories/movies are going to sell. Just like they knew that The Hunger Games and the Twilight series would appeal to the teens and young adult crowd more than children; hence the sexual and love aspects of both stories.
ReplyDeleteThere has been a change in the 21st century when it comes to Disney movies. There has been a shift from dress wearing princesses and valiant knights to ladies doing there own dirty work. Now, princesses like Mulan, and characters like Katniss are venerated, and the Cinderellas have fallen by the wayside. I think characters like katniss are inspiring to many women today. Bella on the other hand, is weak and girly. Two attributes that are frowned upon these days. The difference really seems to lie in the man. Bella likes what her guys like. Katniss is independent. she makes up woman and man all in one. I agree that both movies pair the females with their own mental strengths and weaknesses. Both girls seem to suffer from depression. Katniss even goes crazy by the end of the book. Bella seems emotionless throughout the series. I think movies should focus more on things like physical strength and mental challenges to show young people that they share similar problems, but are also great role models. I hope the trend of making princesses more independent keeps up. I think it will be good for women in the future.
ReplyDelete